Do free trade agreements really create prosperity in Vietnam?

A debate has raged for several decades about the real benefit of free trade agreements and whether they create prosperity for Vietnam, said experts from the Ministry of Industry and Trade at a forum late last month in Hanoi.

At least, with respect to the benefit received from the FTA between the Association of South East Asian Nations, Australia and New Zealand, the answer appears to be – not so much so far – said Phan Thi Dieu Linh of the Ministry. 

Mr Linh, an expert from the Department of Asia-Pacific Market, said now that Vietnam has fulfilled most of its commitments under the Agreement the country is in an appropriate position to assess the contribution of the FTA to its wealth.

On February 27, 2009, ASEAN (Vietnam, Indonesia, Laos, Cambodia, Thailand, Philippines, Malaysia, Singapore, Myanmar and Brunei) signed its biggest trade pact with Australia and New Zealand.

Under the Agreement, Vietnam committed to allow 100% Australian invested entities to operate in the country in respect of higher education, adult education and other education services, including foreign language training and expand fields of study that Australian education providers may choose to provide.

It also reduced the experience requirement to three years for Australian teachers in Vietnam in the following education services – higher secondary education; technical and vocational secondary education; and foreign language training.

As it relates to road transport services, effective January 1, 2010, the Agreement allowed Australian joint venture stakeholders to increase their ownership interest from a noncontrolling 49% to a controlling 51%.

With respect to dairy products, Vietnam committed to progressively reduce tariffs on many Australian dairy products such as milk, butter, whey and yoghurt, by 5% every year, starting in 2010. 

It was agreed that tariffs on milk, milk powder, butter and cheese would be eliminated in 2016 and 2017.

For live animals and meat, the tariff on exports to Vietnam was completely wiped out upon the agreement coming into force, which was January 1, 2010. Other Australian live animals exported to Vietnam were subject to 5% tariffs, which were to be abolished in 2016.

The tariffs of 20% on beef and 30% on pork from Australia were to be phased out initially by 15% and 25%, respectively, in the first year and by approximately 5% every year until they reached zero.

A similar scenario followed for Australian lamb, fruits and juices, with tariffs completely removed by 2016. Wine was an exception with the tariffs on Australian wine remaining at 80% and reduced in one fell swoop to 20% in 2022.

Nguyen Phuc Nam, deputy head of the Department of Asia-Pacific Market, continued to note that in 2009 exports from Vietnam to Australia were US$2.3 billion, which increased 126% to US$2.9 billion in 2016. 

The relatively small increase of US$.6 billion in total sales speaks volumes and shows that at least at this point in time the Agreement has added little to the fortunes of the country in terms of exports and earnings.

At a 5% profit ratio, the total sales figure would equate to only meagre earnings of roughly US$30 million per annum— far off the mark that what was originally expected when the Agreement came into force. 

The opportunity to improve the performance of the economy for exports has been missed so far, said Mr Nam: To date we have simply reduced barriers to the Australia and New Zealand markets and gained access but capitalized very little.

What we have learned is that when, as a country, we fail to properly structure our market-openings brought about by FTAs, we forego the major benefit from the negotiations and don’t enable the country to produce more, generate more sales and in turn earnings.

Consequently, we are forced to conclude that FTAs in and of themselves, like this Agreement, do little to boost the competitiveness of the country’s workforces and private sector in the export arena. 

We need to learn from these lessons and do much more to close the gap between rhetoric and reality and ensure that the FTAs the government enters do in fact create prosperity that results in an improved standard of living for Vietnamese citizens.

VOV

Other News

Vietnam, Russia, Belarus step up cooperation in state audit

Vietnam, Russia, Belarus step up cooperation in state audit

The State Audit Office of Vietnam and the Accounts Chamber of Russia signed an MoU on cooperation and expressed their wish to further expand collaboration at both bilateral and multilateral levels, focusing on the role and impact of supreme audit institutions on macroeconomic policies, digital transformation and the application of information technology to public auditing.

Vietnam, China widen economic, trade cooperation space

Vietnam, China widen economic, trade cooperation space

General Secretary of the Communist Party of Vietnam Central Committee and President To Lam’s trip to China for the 33rd APEC Economic Leaders’ Week and bilateral engagements is expected to add new momentum, including deeper economic connectivity, broader trade, investment and supply chain links, and a more balanced, substantive economic relationship that matches both sides’ potential.

VEFTA implementation requires exporters to restructure supply chains: Experts

VEFTA implementation requires exporters to restructure supply chains: Experts

Under VEFTA, tariff reductions to zero will be meaningless for Vietnam’s key export sectors, including textiles and garments, footwear, and agricultural and aquatic products, if goods are found to contain banned chemicals, violate rules of origin or lack transparency regarding their carbon footprints.

IMF sees positive growth prospects for Vietnam, urges cautious monetary policy

IMF sees positive growth prospects for Vietnam, urges cautious monetary policy

Martin Sommer, head of the IMF’s Article IV consultation mission team to Vietnam, noted that inflation risks in Vietnam remain under control, but several factors could add to price pressures. He therefore called for cautious monetary policy management and readiness to respond promptly if inflationary pressures increased.

Seven green-tech startups secure 770,000 USD at Net Zero Challenge 2026

Seven green-tech startups secure 770,000 USD at Net Zero Challenge 2026

In its fourth year, the competition attracted more than 1,100 applications from 80 countries and territories, making it the most competitive edition since its launch in 2023. Nine finalists presented solutions in three categories, namely renewable energy and carbon removal; food systems and sustainable agriculture; and circular economy and waste management.

Vietnam remains an attractive destination for Japanese businesses

Vietnam remains an attractive destination for Japanese businesses

Fukai Akihiko, President and Representative Director at Gunma Bank and head of a business delegation from Japan’s Gunma prefecture, said cooperation between Gunma and Vietnam has continued to expand in recent years. Around 15,000 Vietnamese people currently live in Gunma, forming the largest foreign community in the prefecture.

Vietnam and Sweden step up cooperation in telecom infrastructure, cybersecurity

Vietnam and Sweden step up cooperation in telecom infrastructure, cybersecurity

Vietnam is accelerating institutional reforms, improving its investment and business environment, developing infrastructure and enhancing human resources quality. The Government stands ready to cooperate with leading global corporations investing in sectors of strategic importance to the country's development.

Vietnam-Japan trade machine has room to run

Vietnam-Japan trade machine has room to run

Economic, trade and investment cooperation remains the core pillar and the main engine of comprehensive, sustainable bilateral ties. General Secretary of the Communist Party of Vietnam Central Committee and President To Lam’s official visit to Japan is therefore a key moment to reinforce political trust, deepen the Comprehensive Strategic Partnership and open new cooperation opportunities in the next growth phase.

Vietnamese goods eye greater access to the Australian market

Vietnamese goods eye greater access to the Australian market

Participants at the Vietnam-Western Australia Business Forum 2026 in Perth on November 6 highlighted strong prospects for Vietnamese rice, agricultural produce and food products in the Australian market as local businesses seek to diversify supply chains.

WTO hails Vietnam's 20-year journey since accession

WTO hails Vietnam's 20-year journey since accession

Joining the World Trade Organisation (WTO) was a strategic choice for Vietnam, closely associated with its Doi Moi (Renewal) process, opening-up policy and international economic integration. Over the past two decades, international economic integration has become a driving force for institutional reforms, trade expansion, foreign investment attraction and enhancement of the country's international standing.

US to send largest-ever agricultural trade mission to Vietnam

US to send largest-ever agricultural trade mission to Vietnam

The USDA’s statistics show that Vietnam was the seventh-largest export market for American agricultural and related products in 2025, with import turnover of nearly 5.6 billion USD. The US’s 2025 agricultural exports to Vietnam increased 38% from 2024.

APEC 2027 seen as fresh impetus for Vietnam-Russia cooperation

APEC 2027 seen as fresh impetus for Vietnam-Russia cooperation

VOV.VN - Vietnam’s hosting of the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) summit in 2027 is expected to create new momentum for cooperation between Vietnam and Russia, with opportunities to expand ties across a range of areas of mutual interest, according to Russian expert Tatyana Gorchakova.