Compensation for expropriated land “detached” from market value

The Government’s mechanism to calculate the compensation rate for residents whose land it takes for public purposes is "detached" from the market value instead of relying on it, leading to prolonged opposition and grievances from those affected.
A corner of Thu Thiem urban area in Ho Chi Minh City (Photo: VNA)

A corner of Thu Thiem urban area in Ho Chi Minh City (Photo: VNA)

Such was the unanimous consensus by experts who gathered last week at a conference held in Hanoi on land policies and regulations, one of the ‘hot button’ issue as the country undergoes a boom in infrastructure development.

Assoc. Prof. Ngo Tri Long, an economist, claimed that the Government’s limit on how much it is willing to pay only equals 20-30 percent of the market value.

“The low compensation makes those who have their land expropriated feel unhappy and unwilling to co-operate during the land clearance process. During any project, land clearance is always one of the biggest bottlenecks that severely delays progress,” Long said.

In Vietnam, the Constitution does not recognise the private ownership of land but insist that land is owned by ’all people’, and the State is to represent this public ownership, managing the allocation of land use rights to individuals or organisations and the transfer of land use rights.

According to a report from the Supreme Court in 2017, the lion’s share of mass complaints is land-related, with 74.6 percent of the cases the courts undertake having to do with land disputes.

The Hanoi People’s Committee’s Decision No 96 determines the land price along several streets – including Hang Dao, Hang Ngang and Le Thai To – in the popular Old Quarter and nearby downtown area at 100-160 million VND (4,300-6,000 USD) per sq.m. These figures are already among the highest in the country, but are only a fraction of the real market value. Each square metre of property along these streets could easily reach 500-800 million VND, or even 1 billion VND, depending on the location.

The controversy that besieges the new Thu Thiem urban area in HCM City, which was originally envisioned to be one of the most modern and developed urban areas in Southeast Asia, is a typical case where inadequate compensation for residents triggered mass protests and a sprawling lawsuit that has endured for more than 20 years.

“The entire land valuation process is being carried out by State administration agencies, sidelining the very ones who have their land expropriated,” Long said, adding that in most cases, the land compensation rate is arbitrary, without independent input.

The land law is an attempt to close the gap between what the Government could reasonably pay as compensation so as not to go over budget and the “market value," but no clear definition for the term has been reached, Assoc. Prof. Hoang Van Cuong, Vice Rector of the National Economics University and a National Assembly deputy said.

“Residents of course want the ‘market value’ to be as close as possible to prevailing transactions in the area," he said, adding that the Government has not found any viable land valuation mechanism to balance its interests and those of affected people.

Another land-related issue highlighted at the conference is the management and use of public land, which has come under scrutiny after the exposure of how lax supervision and legal loopholes have led to severe losses of State assets and undermined the transparency of the real estate market.

Le Hoang Chau, Chairman of the HCM City Real Estate Association, pointed to selling State-owned land use rights to investors without going through a public bidding procedure, underselling State land via obscurity-plagued equitisation of State-owned enterprises or via the Build-Transfer (BT) model where the developers would receive certain land areas for a public-use project they undertake, as usual ways for losses to happen.

There are also cases where State agencies or organisations partner up with private businesses to develop or carry out projects on the public land allocated to them, but the new land use price is not updated when the land is now used for commercial purposes.

Chau urged the Government to soon issue a decree on the use of State assets, especially land, to have a clear legal framework to pay the correct value of land use rights to the projects’ investors that is commensurate with their expenditures.

Nguyen Van Xa, former head of the public asset management department under the finance ministry, said legal issues and violations of the law undermine the gains from land, a highly valuable resource.

“One thing needs to be clear, selling of State-owned land use rights must be done through a public, open bidding procedure,” Xa said.

At the conference, experts urged the early implementation of the national land management database where information could be accessed in a convenient and transparent manner by any citizen or interested business.

The Government would also need to come up with detailed mechanisms that enable non-State actors, especially the public, to monitor the land-related policies and raise the accountability of State agencies and officials in their decision-making.

VNS/VNA

Other News

Vietnamese culture connects generations in Canada

Vietnamese culture connects generations in Canada

Beyond language skills, children learn about Vietnamese history, stories of filial devotion and national heroes, and the importance of respecting parents and teachers. Weekend classes begin with the national anthem, while festivals and traditional holidays offer opportunities to make greeting cards, prepare traditional cakes and learn to wrap 'banh chung' (square sticky rice cakes).

Vietnam Studies Centre opens in northeastern Thailand

Vietnam Studies Centre opens in northeastern Thailand

The centre would serve as a valuable academic hub for teaching and promoting Vietnamese language, culture and history, while fostering people-to-people exchanges and connecting younger generations of the two countries.

950 years of Quoc Tu Giam: A milestone in Vietnam's educational and cultural history

950 years of Quoc Tu Giam: A milestone in Vietnam's educational and cultural history

Russia’s senior researcher in Oriental studies Dr. Anatoly Sokolov said that although founded nearly a millennium ago, Quoc Tu Giam remains far more than a historical monument. It has continued to pass on the tradition of learning to successive generations and remained an integral part of Vietnam’s cultural and educational life.

Vietnam plans to go green by expanding ASEAN eco-schools model

Vietnam plans to go green by expanding ASEAN eco-schools model

At the launch ceremony, Deputy Minister of Agriculture and Environment Le Trong Yen said schools play an important role in shaping young people's knowledge, character, and habits. Daily practices such as saving electricity and water, sorting waste and caring for trees could help students understand the value of natural resources and their responsibility towards the environment, while spreading positive habits to families and communities.

Young generation helps strengthen Vietnam–RoK friendship

Young generation helps strengthen Vietnam–RoK friendship

Through the seminar and bilingual contest, VESAMO aimed to provide a platform for young people to share knowledge, pursue their aspirations and contribute to closer friendship and comprehensive cooperation between the two nations.

Vietnamese community in Japan is encouraged to further contribute to national development

Vietnamese community in Japan is encouraged to further contribute to national development

Welcoming the Vietnamese community's efforts and contributions, the General Secretary and President affirmed that the Party and State will continue improving institutions and policies to create favorable conditions for overseas Vietnamese to engage more deeply in the country's socio-economic development and play a proactive role as partners and co-creators in nation-building.

Ho Chi Minh City pushes English as a second language in schools

Ho Chi Minh City pushes English as a second language in schools

In 2027-2028, Ho Chi Minh City targets 20-30% of managers, teachers and staff in English proficiency training, 30% of establishments providing training in English/STEM/STEAM teaching methods, at least 30% of educational establishments with a complete English-speaking environment, and at least 15% of educational establishments teaching subjects in English.

Empowering people with disabilities to be immune to online scams

Empowering people with disabilities to be immune to online scams

Notably, it has organized online scam prevention training courses for more than 1,000 young people with disabilities. In coordination with the Hanoi Police, it has also run awareness campaigns and guided members on identifying fraudulent schemes, protecting their accounts and personal data, and verifying information before sharing it on social media.

New plan aims to empower people with disabilities, promote social inclusion

New plan aims to empower people with disabilities, promote social inclusion

By 2030, Vietnam aims to ensure social security and improve the quality of life of people with disabilities, with priority given to those facing hardship or unable to support themselves. It also aims to ensure their appropriate participation in elected bodies and enable them to benefit from the country's development achievements.

Vietnam advances towards high-quality, specialised healthcare

Vietnam advances towards high-quality, specialised healthcare

Recent developments in Hanoi and other localities highlight efforts to develop specialised treatment, standardise professional practices and apply artificial intelligence (AI) and advanced medical techniques, towards a more modern healthcare system.

Vietnam, US step up technology cooperation in search for war martyrs' remains

Vietnam, US step up technology cooperation in search for war martyrs' remains

Addressing a dialogue on war legacies in Southeast Asia organised by the Stimson Centre in Washington, D.C on October 21, Vietnamese Ambassador to the US Nguyen Quoc Dung briefed representatives of US government agencies, non-governmental organisations and experts on Vietnam’s efforts to address war consequences, while calling for international support and cooperation in urgent humanitarian work.